Read + Write + Report
Home | Start a blog | About Orble | FAQ | Sites | Writers | Advertise | My Orble | Login

Sport: The Australian Disease - sportingaustralia.com

Cricket- to thine ownself be true

October 8th 2008 06:52
cricket
Twenty20 cricket has turned out to be something of a Hydra: whenever tournaments are cancelled, or teams are forced to withdraw, there always seems to be two to take their place.

Meanwhile, since Sport: The Australian Disease last covered the format, even more fixtures and tournaments have been dreamed up by giddy administrators. The Australian international season will now be ushered in by a match between the national team and the hallowed Australian Cricketers’ Association All-Stars, while in 2009, Australia, India and South Africa will do battle in Twenty20’s first ever tri-series. Tellingly, a window has yet to be allocated for this so-called “super series”, because the three participating countries have overloaded their schedules with so many meaningless fixtures that it has thus far proved impossible to find. Presumably, though, a block of time will somehow be manufactured, if only because a lot of money is riding on it. One can only wonder where it will all end- certainly not at any logical position, because as far as Twenty20 is concerned, we have long since passed into the realms of madness.


Yet remarkably, as the game enthusiastically sells its soul to the highest bidder, a confluence of circumstances has allowed a test tour, with all the traditional values it entails, to take centre stage in the cricketing world. Thanks to the cancellation of the Champions Trophy and the postponement of the Twenty20 Champions League, no top-level cricket is currently taking place. All eyes have therefore been focussed on Australia’s visit to India.


From the moment that the tourists landed just over a fortnight ago, the sense of anticipation has been keen, and continued to grow by the day. And while most of that anticipation has come from the two nations’ supporters, the amount of interest being shown by fans- and players- from other countries should not be underestimated. For what this test series is promising is something that no contrived limited overs tournament can hope to deliver: acute- and memorable- drama.

The glory of a competitive test series is that it provides all the depth and tension and emotion of an intricately crafted work of literature. The characters enthral, their foibles, heartaches and triumphs fascinate, so that in much the same way that it hurts to have to put down a good book, one feels a wrench that the day’s play or the match itself should have to come to an end. The best series capture the imagination and live long in the memory, just like the greatest classics. Lovers of the game can talk as reverently and expansively about the 2005 Ashes, the 2001 Border-Gavaskar Trophy and the 1960-61 Frank Worrell Trophy as a scholar would of Hamlet. A Twenty20 match, however, is nothing more than a comic strip, providing a short burst of entertainment that will most likely be forgotten the moment the next one comes along.

Since the turn of the century, India and Australia have established a rivalry that Sachin Tendulkar believes to be even greater than that between India and Pakistan. This bold claim has nothing to do with the 20 or 50 over battles that they have fought, but the four intense test series that the two countries have participated in. India 2001 is remembered for the hosts’ extraordinary comeback; Australia 2003-4 is remembered for Steve Waugh’s farewell; India 2004 is remembered for the visitors’ conquest of their final frontier; and Australia 2007-8 is remembered for the controversial Sydney test. The important thing is that they are remembered. All have been highly competitive and combative series, with the result that all have been dramatic, and all memorable. Who, by contrast, can possibly remember the last four one-day series that India and Australia have contested?

To merely reminisce about recent Border-Gavaskar showdowns is to understand how magnificent cricket can be. It is also to lament the degrading state that the sport has chosen to accept. Most supporters would probably agree that there is a place for the shorter forms of the game. After all, they are capable of providing genuine- if superficial- enjoyment, whilst attracting new fans and earning significant revenues. They must not, however, be regarded as the equal of test cricket, but complements, existing principally to highlight its greatness. Fewer of these limited overs matches would help to redress the balance. They would also make the limited overs matches more meaningful, and thus more exciting. And if these matches were more exciting, they would, in turn, compel people to ponder how much more satisfying five days of quality cricket could be.

Such considerations are of great importance, because in these changing times, the sport’s survival is uncertain. What is needed in cricket today is not more money- the game is already swimming in it, and in danger of drowning. What is needed in cricket today is cricket. There is no need for another Champions this or Super that; there is no need for more colourful clothing or blaring music; there is no need for jaded players to be dispatched to Malaysia or Canada. What is needed to ensure the sport’s survival is not ersatz cricket, but real cricket, of the kind that Australia and India are about to play. Somebody at the ICC needs to assume the role of Hercules and confront the Hydra before it is too late.
23
Vote
   


Nicky Carle
Let us declare it official: Nicky Carle is the Peter Hewat of Australian football.

In May 2007, Hewat was famously omitted from a 59 man training squad that then-Wallabies coach John Connolly assembled prior to the World Cup. Now, Carle has been omitted from a 35 man squad that Socceroos coach Pim Verbeek has assembled prior to the qualifier against Qatar.

Every now and then, a player will arrive on the scene to polarise opinion. Some will proclaim him or her an exceptional talent; others will consider the person in question to be overrated. Facts and figures will be bandied about in support of both sides of the argument; tempers will rise as supporters and detractors alike shake their heads at the apparent absurdity of the other’s position. Who knows why, but two people will look at the same picture and see something completely different. Although the endless debate can be maddening, it is ultimately to be celebrated; after all, it is the subjective beauty of sport, allied with its capacity to arouse passions and stir debate, that makes it so grand. Sport is capable of stimulating every possible emotion- be it rapture, wonder, astonishment or despair- to the extent that so many of us feel compelled to follow and discuss it. Even as it draws people apart it brings them together.

Peter Hewat was only on the rugby union scene from 2005-7, yet in that short time he was responsible for a good many arguments. Supporters of the NSW fullback seemed to like him for objective reasons; anybody who scores so many tries and kicks so many penalties, they insisted, must be good. Opponents, however, took a subjective line; his defence is shaky and he goes missing in big games.

As Hewat was arriving on the Super 14 scene, Wendell Sailor was preparing to leave it. He, too, polarised opinion- and, perhaps not coincidentally, in much the same way. Supporters hailed his try-scoring record and pointed to the number of metres he would gain per match. Opponents countered that his erratic defence and lack of rugby nous made him a liability. The key difference is that Sailor found favour with the national selectors. What they had in common is that both were highly unconventional.

Beauty, we all know, is in the eye of the beholder. But there are some things that are manifestly beautiful, or appealing. Audrey Hepburn was manifestly beautiful in a way that Sarah Jessica Parker is not; staying in a five star hotel is manifestly appealing in a way that camping in the bush is not. Some things the human brain will readily accept as pleasing; others demand a great deal of effort. To appreciate an unconventional athlete like a Hewat or a Sailor demands effort. Of course, whether such effort is deserved is another matter.

As far as John Connolly was concerned, Peter Hewat was not so much oddly beautiful as ugly, to the extent that he was not even considered amongst the 59 fairest players in the land. Having looked for beauty and found none, Knuckles did not care how many people may have swooned at the sight of Hewat, nor how ardently those admirers might have pressed for him to see things from a different angle; the boy was ugly and that was that.

The sight of Nicky Carle with the ball at his feet makes many fans swoon, but it appears that Pim Verbeek is not one of them. Some will consider this unsurprising, for if ever there was a player guaranteed to polarise observers of Australian football, it was surely Carle. After all, Nicky doesn’t do conventional. He doesn’t throw himself around like a Matt Simon, he doesn’t run all day like a Brett Emerton, he doesn’t hound opponents like a Vinny Grella- in fact, he doesn’t do anything the way we are accustomed to see it done. For Australians to admire a footballer, he usually has to be beautiful in an obvious way- a Hepburn, or, more to the point, a Pamela Anderson. And God knows that Nicky Carle is no Pamela Anderson.

That Graham Arnold, when he was Socceroos boss, did not hold a high opinion of Carle was only to be expected. He wanted his team to produce a physical style of football, in which the opposition would be outmuscled rather than outthought. The subtle gifts of Carle were wasted on a coach who valued athleticism over the ability to caress the ball, or play the incisive pass.



What is unexpected, though, is that Verbeek should also look down on Carle. Aren’t the Dutch meant to value technique over physique? To be sure, Verbeek has shown himself to be a pragmatist, but surely there is room for artists and artisans in the same team? It’s all very well including the likes of Grella and Carl Valeri to win the ball, but shouldn’t it then be given to somebody who knows how to use it?

Even Carle’s staunchest supporters acknowledge that there are several people ahead of him in the queue- Harry Kewell, Tim Cahill and Marco Bresciano, no less- while he also faces stiff competition from Jason Culina, Brett Holman, Mile Sterjovski and Scott McDonald. But how could Verbeek consider Shannon Cole, who was included in his squad, to be amongst the 35 best players in the country and not Carle? Cole has played a total of six top-flight games in his career, yet he is already adjudged a better prospect than the 2006-07 A-League player of the year. How is this possible?

The only explanation is the one that has already been given: beauty really is in the eye of the beholder. Different characteristics may catch different people’s eyes, but when somebody looks you over and decides that you’re ugly, no amount of preening is going to change their opinion. To adopt a metaphor that has lately been in vogue, you can put lipstick on a pig, but it’s still a pig. Pim Verbeek has looked Nicky Carle over and decided that he doesn’t like what he sees. Peter Hewat would no doubt advise Carle not to expect him expect him to change his mind anytime soon.
28
Vote
   


Adelaide v Kashima
Thanks to a 1-0 victory at home to Kashima, Adelaide has advanced to the Asian Champions League semi finals

Whichever way you look at it, the mathematics doesn’t make pleasant reading for Adelaide United.

Tomorrow, when the Reds take on Newcastle at Hindmarsh Stadium, they will be playing their fifth match in 15 days. Starting from the following round, they will then have six matches to grind through in 23 days. Put together, from the away game against Melbourne on September 12 to the home game against Perth on October 26, it equates to 11 matches in 44 days.

Unfortunate though this fixture congestion is, the reason for it is a happy one. Thanks to Wednesday night’s stirring victory over Kashima Antlers, Adelaide has won through to an Asian Champions League semi final meeting with Bunyodkor. That means that in addition to fulfilling its weekly A-League commitments, the club must participate in a gruelling two-legged contest with the Uzbeks, just a fortnight after concluding its exhausting tie against the reigning Japanese champions.



The FFA must now find a way to ease this fixture congestion. For should Adelaide make it through to the final- and even win it- the whole Australian footballing community stands to benefit.

While the A-League can never hope to attain the status of Europe’s top competitions, it can- and must- do everything possible to ensure its place amongst Asia’s elite. That is an exceptionally difficult task when one considers the prestige enjoyed by the Japanese and Korean leagues, the continuing rise of the Chinese Super League, and the enormous sums of money being bandied about by other rivals. Qatar’s Q-League, for example, currently boasts the services of Hakan Yakin, Younis Mahmoud and Nashat Akram, while it has also played host to luminaries such as Romario, Gabriel Batistuta, Fernando Hierro, Marcel Desailly and Stefan Effenberg- players who, presumably, came not for the balmy weather but the cash. There are even some in Uzbekistan’s Oliy League with deep pockets: a month ago, Bunyodkor signed the brilliant Rivaldo, before appointing Zico as its coach.

Of course, the A-League seems unlikely to ever match the wealth of the J-League, K-League and CSL, and can’t hope to compete with the Middle East’s oil money. Still, if Australian clubs are able to offer players reasonable salaries, then several other factors could enable them to out-recruit richer competitions. Lifestyle and climate are obvious selling points, but it is also important to be able to offer a high standard of play. If the A-League can build a reputation for producing quality Asian teams and even Champions League winners, it becomes a more appealing destination for footballers.

Concomitantly, it becomes a more appealing place for sponsors to invest. Persuading companies to part with their money is demanding at the best of times- and given the financial crisis that has gripped the world, it will surely become an even greater challenge. Sponsors love to be associated with success, just as they enjoy having their brands exposed to as many potential consumers as possible. If Australian clubs are winning games in Asia and parading their logos with distinction, companies will become keener to do business with the A-League.

It is important to realise that in much the same way that Australian football is locked in a fierce civil war with Aussie Rules, rugby league and rugby union, so it is doing battle with the other 45 members of the Asian Football Confederation. Everyone is trying to lure as many skilful players and as many corporate dollars to their leagues as possible, and thus everyone is trying to make their leagues as alluring as possible. An unlikely Champions League triumph for Adelaide would benefit Australian football, because it would increase the prestige of the A-League in the eyes of players and sponsors.

That means that it is incumbent on the FFA to provide Adelaide with all the assistance it could reasonably be expected to offer. The obvious place to start would be with easing its fixture congestion. Just because Manchester United and Real Madrid are regularly asked to cope with such hectic schedules, doesn’t mean that Adelaide should be expected to- after all, those European powerhouses possess far greater playing resources, not to mention considerably more experience in marshalling them. Last weekend’s game against Sydney FC showed how out of its depth Adelaide currently finds itself. Having played away to Melbourne eight days before and away to Kashima only three days before, and with the knowledge that the crucial second leg against the Japanese was just four days away, the Reds produced a predictably listless performance. Their 3-0 defeat was the product of exhausted bodies and unfocussed minds.

When Adelaide host Bunyodkor on October 8 and play the return leg on October 22, it is imperative that there are fresh bodies and focussed minds to call upon. That means that the FFA should give serious thought to postponing the home match against Central Coast on the 3rd- and it means that the FFA should definitely postpone the away match against Queensland on the 17th. At the same time, the other seven A-League clubs should forget about the short-term advantage they would gain from Adelaide’s logistical nightmare, and realise that it is in their long term interest to help reduce it. That means that if requests are made to alter fixtures, they should be received sympathetically.

Although it is Adelaide fans who will have been cheering the loudest since Wednesday night, United’s win over Kashima was really a victory for all clubs, and thus one to celebrate by all fans. All reasonable measures must therefore be taken to give Adelaide the best possible chance of progressing to the final, because as Sport: The Australian Disease has argued before, a win for Adelaide is a win for Australian football.
18
Vote
Shared on
   


From Eagle to Magpie?
Nothing could be more heart-warming than a tale of redemption. Only the most unsympathetic of fellows would deny a troubled soul a second chance. We all make mistakes. Nobody’s perfect.

These will be just some of the clichés emanating from AFL clubs over the following weeks, as the race for Ben Cousins’s signature begins in earnest


[ Click here to read more ]
43
Vote
Shared on
   


Sydney FC coach John Kosmina
What, exactly, does Kossie have against the human body?

If Sydney FC coach John Kosmina isn’t choking players, he’s putting his foot in his mouth with alarming regularity


[ Click here to read more ]
28
Vote
Shared on
   


If you build it, will they come?

September 10th 2008 07:02
Swans v Kangaroos
Masses of empty seats at Saturday night's elimination final


If you build it, will they come


[ Click here to read more ]
34
Vote
Shared on
   


Meet the new Lion King

September 3rd 2008 12:30
Brisbane Lions' new coach
Rugby fans: imagine, if you will, the following scenario.

With the Tri Nations delicately poised, and with the Bledisloe Cup on the line, the Australian Rugby Union decides to take a gamble, dumping Robbie Deans and replacing him with Tim Horan for the upcoming test match against New Zealand


[ Click here to read more ]
35
Vote
Shared on
   


Stalin
During the time of Stalin, it was the fate of many senior Bolsheviks to fall foul of the Great Father of the Soviet Union. Typically, these ex-leaders would not merely be tortured and executed, but also deleted from the historical record, as if they had never existed. Their images would be airbrushed from photographs, their portraits would be removed from government buildings, their deeds would be edited out of encyclopaedias, their names would be taken out of textbooks. They would become ‘unpersons’.

Tony Zappia, the chief executive of the Cronulla Sharks, seems to be a student of history, because Greg Bird has just begun to disappear from his club’s historical record. Although he has yet to be airbrushed from the team photo, and although he is still on the contract list, he is no longer to be found amongst the player profiles
[ Click here to read more ]
35
Vote
Shared on
   


Boomers
And so, like the Olyroos before them, the Boomers have been bounced out of Beijing.

But how different the circumstances. The Olyroos played meekly and unimaginatively, so that not only did they get what they deserved, they deprived themselves of any meaningful opportunity to progress to the knockout rounds. The Boomers, by contrast, played with spirit and thought, understanding that not only was it better to go down fighting, but that in fighting they were less likely to go down


[ Click here to read more ]
54
Vote
Shared on
   


Graham Arnold
And so, the Olyroos have fallen at the first hurdle.

Sometimes, the losing side can display so much skill that it does not deserve to be beaten- like Australia during its World Cup playoff defeat by Iran in 1997. Sometimes, the losing side can display so much gallantry that it does not deserve to be beaten- like Australia during its World Cup playoff defeat by Argentina in 1993. Sadly, though, this Australian side was neither skilful enough nor gallant enough to deserve anything other than its early elimination from the Olympics


[ Click here to read more ]
34
Vote
Shared on
   


More Posts
2 Posts
5 Posts
5 Posts
33 Posts dating from April 2008
Email Subscription
Receive e-mail notifications of new posts on this blog:

Nick Bendel's Blogs

I have no other blogs :(
Moderated by Nick Bendel
Copyright © 2006 2007 2008 On Topic Media PTY LTD. All Rights Reserved. Design by Vimu.com.
On Topic Media ZPages: Sydney |  Melbourne |  Brisbane |  London |  Birmingham |  Leeds     [ Advertise ] [ Contact Us ] [ Privacy Policy ]